Turmeric is touted to have anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial and anti-cancer properties that act towards a number of circumstances, together with arthritis, respiratory infections and diabetes. Clinical trials haven’t produced rigorous proof to help these broad claims, but turmeric stays one of many top-selling herbal supplements in the USA.
With many individuals taking turmeric in concentrated complement kind, a troubling pattern has emerged. Lately, turmeric has been implicated in a rising variety of instances of acute liver harm, a few of which have led to liver transplant and even dying.
“Turmeric-induced liver harm is taken into account uncommon — one in 10,000 and even 100,000 individuals who take it would get sick — however now, tens of millions of persons are taking turmeric,” mentioned Jay Hoofnagle, director of the Liver Illness Analysis Department within the Division of Digestive Ailments and Vitamin on the Nationwide Institutes of Well being (NIH). “Primarily based on what we’re seeing in our knowledge, it’s one of the vital widespread causes of dietary complement liver harm.”
Dietary supplements have extra curcumin
Fashionable preparations of the turmeric plant, which has been utilized in conventional drugs and as a spice in meals for 1000’s of years, mixed with a genetic susceptibility in sure sufferers, is almost definitely the reason for liver harm, specialists mentioned.
Dietary supplements include high-dose purified extracts of curcumin, the principle energetic ingredient of turmeric that solely makes up between 1 and 7 percent of the foundation. Many additionally include components resembling black pepper to advertise absorption of curcumin, a substance that’s sometimes poorly absorbed by the digestive tract.
For instance, a study that gave human topics 2 grams of curcumin may barely detect it in blood samples. However after including black pepper, the fraction of curcumin that reached the bloodstream shot up by 2,000 p.c.
“Individuals immediately are taking 100 instances extra curcumin than what was utilized in conventional drugs,” Hoofnagle mentioned. “I am going to Costco and see these huge bottles of turmeric with black pepper, a gram per serving, and I believe, ‘Oh my goodness.’ ”
Hoofnagle supervises the Drug-Induced Liver Injury Network (DILIN), an NIH-sponsored initiative that collects and analyzes instances of extreme liver harm attributable to medicine and different medicines. In 2022, the DILIN reported 10 cases of liver injury related to turmeric dietary supplements. The commonest signs had been jaundice, nausea and belly ache. Of the ten instances, 5 sufferers had been hospitalized, and one affected person died of acute liver failure.
The researchers concluded that liver harm due to turmeric seems to be rising in the USA, and the rising reputation of turmeric during the last 5 years appears to reflect the rise in reported instances collected by the DILIN.
Instances have additionally been reported elsewhere on this planet. A 2020 study described seven instances of acute noninfectious hepatitis that occurred in Italy, all linked to turmeric dietary supplements. In August 2023, the Australian authorities printed a safety advisory warning shoppers and health-care professionals that turmeric dietary supplements might trigger liver harm in uncommon instances. The advisory got here after the Division of Well being and Aged Care acquired 18 stories of turmeric-associated liver issues, together with one which had a deadly consequence.
“Individuals assume that turmeric is of course occurring and over-the-counter, so it have to be innocent, which isn’t true,” mentioned Ken Liu, a transplant hepatologist on the Australian Nationwide Liver Transplant Unit. “As a clinician, I’ve observed increasingly more folks admitted to the hospital for having liver harm from natural and dietary dietary supplements and needing liver transplants for this.”
Fadi Alghzawi, a resident doctor at MedStar Union Memorial Hospital in Baltimore, has additionally observed an uptick in turmeric-related instances. He not too long ago noticed a 66-year-old African American woman who was admitted to the emergency division with jaundice, nausea, decreased urge for food and darkish urine. Testing revealed starkly elevated bilirubin ranges within the blood — 29 mg/dL when 0.2 to 1.1 mg/dL is taken into account regular — indicating doable liver dysfunction.
After ruling out all different causes and confirming with a liver biopsy, turmeric was discovered to be the wrongdoer. Six months earlier, the affected person began taking half a teaspoon of floor turmeric as an natural treatment from a retailer. Though she discontinued the turmeric upon admission to the hospital, it was too late.
“Normally when folks cease taking turmeric or any natural complement that’s inflicting harm, it’s best to see enchancment,” Alghzawi mentioned. “Nonetheless, on this case, irreversible harm occurred to the liver, and inside seven days of admission, she handed away.”
Drug-induced liver injury, which may be categorised as both direct or idiosyncratic, is probably the most frequent explanation for acute liver failure in most Western international locations. Direct harm is predictable, dose-dependent, and attributable to brokers which can be intrinsically poisonous to the liver, resembling acetaminophen. Idiosyncratic harm, alternatively, is way trickier to diagnose and deal with. It solely impacts inclined people, and the accountable brokers have little to no intrinsic toxicity.
“Idiosyncratic harm means you’re taking a drugs, after which based mostly in your gender, age or immune standing, it will possibly abruptly trigger a liver harm,” Alghzawi mentioned. “You can not predict it, and it’s not dose-dependent.”
For instance, ladies are more prone to drug-induced liver harm than males due to variations in hormonal standing, physique composition, metabolism and different elements. African American patients could also be liable to extra extreme liver harm and worse illness outcomes, resembling liver transplant or dying, after drug-related liver harm than White sufferers.
Genetics can also be a part of the story, since sure genes encode for enzymes concerned in drug processing. After a drug is ingested, it will get absorbed by the gastrointestinal tract and brought up by the bloodstream. The primary place it goes is the liver, whose job it’s to take away toxins and metabolize medicine utilizing particular enzymes. The research by the DILIN discovered that 7 of the ten sufferers carried a genetic variant, present in solely 10 p.c of the U.S. basic inhabitants, that will have elevated their susceptibility to turmeric-associated liver harm.
“These liver enzymes are dictated by genetics, so the way you metabolize one thing is perhaps barely totally different to how I metabolize one thing,” Liu mentioned. “You would possibly metabolize curcumin as a totally inert, innocent metabolite, whereas I’d metabolize it as one thing that’s poisonous and inflammatory to the liver.”
Each health-care suppliers and shoppers ought to pay attention to the doable dangers earlier than taking turmeric as a complement. Alghzawi even thinks that taking turmeric as a complement must be averted altogether, since its purported advantages don’t outweigh the dangers. Different specialists consider in a extra measured method.
“Whereas it is probably not essential to keep away from turmeric dietary supplements altogether, it is vital for sufferers to tell their medical doctors of their use in order that monitoring may be executed, if wanted,” mentioned Angeline Liu, a gastroenterologist with Kaiser Permanente in southern California. “Likewise, it is vital for physicians to take a whole historical past when talking with sufferers, which incorporates routinely asking sufferers if they’re taking any medicines or dietary supplements that may be bought over-the-counter.”
Do you’ve a query about wholesome consuming? Electronic mail [email protected] and we might reply your query in a future column.
